3 comments. This seems directly analogous to what happened between Grindelwald and Dumbledore. It never ceases to amaze me how many Potterfans miss the “story within a story” element of the Deathly Hallows. And then I came to the conclusion that Dumbledore, McGonagall, and Hermione (all three were seriously considered for sorting into Ravenclaw by the Sorting Hat) thought that Divination was very inaccurate and not exact. Grindelwald stole it in a proper manner so it worked for him. Possession The duel was one of the most well known duels in the world, and one of Dumbledore's most famous moments, with Dumbledore winning the duel and the Elder Wand's allegiance. Could you explain how a duel where Grindelwald tries to die but Dumbledore refuses to kill him would work? That Grindelwald simply conjured a handkerchief from his wand. How was Dumbledore able to defeat Grindelwald, since Grindelwald had the Elder Wand? But the Elder Wand is supposed to greatly enhance the powers of the wielder. “What must strike any intelligent witch or wizard on studying the so-called history of the Elder Wand is that every man who claims to have owned it28 has insisted that it is “unbeatable,” when the known facts of its passage through many owners’ hands demonstrate that has it not only been beaten hundreds of times, but that it also attracts trouble as Grumble the Grubby Goat attracted flies.” - The Tales of Beedle the Bard. If Grindlewald chose not to fight but to come quietly due to a relationship with Dumbledore, I'd say that doesn't fall into the category of "winning the wand". Dumbledore believed that it might be possible for him to destroy the blood pact when it was given to him by Newt, but seemed unsure on whether he would succeed.[5]. [1], Gellert Grindelwald was captured and detained in the top-most cell of Nurmengard, a prison that he himself had constructed to hold his enemies. Perhaps Grindelwald takes some Seer visions he will see too literally and then acts based on those Seer vision and then they are actually wrong or refers to ambiguous entities, and Dumbledore wins because Grindelwald interpreted them incorrectly. you can win the elder wand when u disarm (expelliarmus) your opponent hence it is the skill of the duellers that is … of the Elder Wand does Community content is available under. just speculates on the transfer of ownership of the Elder Wand. Although Grindelwald was sinister and Dumbledore was noble, they shared one very disturbing trait: both men manipulated… Dumbledore seized upon the moment to disarm Grindlewald to win the duel. At some time before 1945, the blood pact was destroyed by unknown means. Aberforth became concerned with Dumbledore's ambitions. With the outcry having become too vocal and Grindelwald's actions too horrible for Dumbledore to ignore, he confronted his old friend. He was not the owner. Result At the age of six, she was seen practising magic by a group of Muggle boys. That’s 45 to 46 years of Seer visions. Harry Potter. How can my level 3 party defeat a group of Liches? Location Decades before the legendary Duel, Gellert Grindelwald had come to Godric's Hollow to stay with his great aunt, Bathilda Bagshot. 3 years ago. Dumbledore should have allowed Harry to win it from him before burying himself with it. In Short: Dumbledore was sustained by Fawkes Phoenix powers, Grindelwald eventually tired, gave in to Dumbledore. The first LEGO set for the new movie is called “Grindelwald’s Escape”, and combined with the new trailer, gives a bit of a hint as to how he might escape.. Grindelwald took it How was Dumbledore able to defeat Grindelwald when he was facing the most powerful wand ever made? I don’t believe so. What wand was used by Mr Graves at the time of Fantastic Beasts? Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is a fictional character in J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter series. Elder wand is unbeatable. Because Death itself gave it to first brother, saying that the wand will win any duels for the owner. I don't think that it 'greatly enhance[s] the power of the wielder'; from the Tales of Beedle the Bard: "...so the oldest brother, who was a combative man, asked for a wand more powerful than any in existence: @Mooz Harry's wand broke and one of the greatest wand makers of the day said it could not be repaired. Knowing that you're going to duel with another wizard at some ill-defined point in the future doesn't mean that you'll be victorious. Skeeter discovered that Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald were once close friends, and that the young Dumbledore even shared Grindelwald's philosophy for a time. [Source], The Duel between Albus Dumbledore and Dark Wizard Gellert Grindelwald took place in 1945, before Dumbledore's ascension to the position of Headmaster of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, and ended the Global wizarding war. If the duel between Dumbledore and Grindelwald was strictly about wand versus wand then you would be correct in that Grindelwald should have won. The scene in which Grindelwald reveals Credence's true identity is a fascinating one. Why am I getting AbstractDynamicObject$CustomMessageMissingMethodException error? Quite simply, he was powerful (and clever) enough to defeat Grindelwald even with the Elder wand on Grindelwald's side. Their explanation was that as Grindelwald was not the worthy possessor of the wand (just like Dumbledore and Voldemort weren't either) it truly wasn't the unbeatable wand. In what way is the Elder Wand more powerful than a regular wand? [6], Albus Dumbledore returned to his place in Hogwarts, and eventually became Headmaster until his death in 1997. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry Potter Page to Screen: The Complete Filmmaking Journey, LEGO Harry Potter: Building the Magical World, LEGO Harry Potter: Characters of the Magical World, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, Magic Beyond Words: The J.K. Rowling Story, Creator: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 (video game), Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald - The Original Screenplay, https://harrypotter.fandom.com/wiki/Duel_between_Albus_Dumbledore_and_Gellert_Grindelwald?oldid=1424643. The Elder Wand was indeed powerful but, despite the legend that sprang up around it, it did not make its owner unbeatable. Did Aurelius Dumbledore Really Defeat Grindelwald? The spectacular final battle between Dumbledore and Grindelwald took place in 1945, the final year of World War Two, and the year that Voldemort finished Hogwarts. That is, the three most powerful wizards of all time in the Harry Potter universe needed Seers in some way to stay in power. If you sliced the moon in half perfectly, would it hold together? The Elder Wand The Legend: Crafted by Death himself from an Elder Tree. Albus's younger brother, Aberforth, intervened and pointed out the impossibilities of the scheme. Dumbledore beat Grindelwald because without a doubt, Dumbledore was the most powerful wizard in the series (as far as we know, he may have been the most powerful wizard of all time: he invented magical items of his own, he worked on the 12 uses of dragons blood, worked in alchemy with flamel, etc...) What's the opposite of the phrase "pay under the table"? This trio comprised the Eld… Dumbledore never took the subject, and McGonagall and Hermione shared the skepticism and personal dislike of Trelawney. Does any other wand share the same core as the Elder Wand? There’s more steps that one can take to prevent or help make the Seer vision a reality. His victory in this battle would be published on his Chocolate Frog Card and award him an order of Merlin first class. Dumbledore must have just been better on the day. Thus was Dumbledore able to out maneuver Grindelwald, either through a superior control/knowledge of magic and/or by being more cunning, and so Dumbledore defeated Grindelwald. Question. Grindelwald knew he wasn't a match for Dumbledore on even terms: Over the years, Grindelwald raised an army and began a reign of terror that spread through several European countries and murdered many wizards and Muggles, though he never attempted to take power in Britain for his fear of his former friend, Dumbledore, who was "a shade more skillful" than he was. Gellert and Albus used to be lovers, and Gellert may have killed Ariana. Dumbledore himself stated at one point that the future can not be fully predicted due to the consequences of every single present action taken. just like site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. If the EW had made anyone invincible, all the people trying to steal it would have died but we see it is actually the opposite. @Valorum, if you saw the duel and trained yourself to block or avoid those attacks in the present, then you just might be victorious. [1] Grindelwald remained there for the rest of his life until his death at the hands of the only Dark Wizard more powerful and dangerous than himself, Lord Voldemort, after refusing to give him information about the Elder Wand. Why did Dumbledore choose to use the Elder wand rather than his previous one? Oh no hang on, it will work if you want to kill them and tear part of your soul out of them…. I think that nobody mentioned in the Potter books could explicitly be stated as the wand's true owner after the Peverell brother was murdered. his spells will be If they were evenly matched, and even if Dumbledore was only "a shade more skillful", the Elder Wand should have given Griendelwald such a huge edge that Dumbledore would have been decimated. That's not impossible, but requires some additional legwork, certainly. Not complaining but what happened to Dumbledore’s robes? I would think that Dumbledore would need to be immensely more skillful to defeat one with the Elder Wand, otherwise it isn't much of a Legendary weapon. There’s also the fact that Grindelwald is a Seer. rev 2021.5.11.39272. Harry was however able to use the elder wand to repair his broken one, surely an example of the power of the elder wand not related to dueling. One could say that since Voldemort became a more powerful dark wizard than Grindelwald, and Harry beat Voldemort, Harry could beat Grindelwald, but this isn’t true. We know how important Sybill Trelawney was to Dumbledore. [7], *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I mean, Grindelwald would not see Dumbledore for some 45 to 46 years, since the last time they meet is in 1899, and the legendary duel happened in 1945. What carries the information for Pauli exclusion principle to occur? nymphadora_nat. Thus was Dumbledore able to out maneuver Grindelwald, either through a superior control/knowledge of magic and/or by being more cunning, and so Dumbledore defeated Grindelwald. Why do typical DC motors use brush contacts rather than just conductors? I believe based on the Harry Potter universe rules, that after a lengthy duel, the contest tilted in Grindlewald's favor with the help of the Elder wand, but he hesitated on the fatal blow. [1], A young Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald, Decades before the legendary Duel, Gellert Grindelwald had come to Godric's Hollow to stay with his great aunt, Bathilda Bagshot. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. How Did Dumbledore Defeat Grindelwald? First, he tells Credence about the origin of the Dumbledore family's phoenix in their time of need; that comment, and the phoenix's very presence, are clearly intended to reassure viewers that Grindelwald is telling the truth about Credence's identity. it would make sense that he would have a Horcrux. Commanders By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Harry Potter Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Then he may have been the owner of the Elder wand since then. Wand to wand they were even, skill to skill, Dumbledore wins hands down, @Ben was a time in which he knew Grindelwald to be in possession of the elder wand. If Grindelwald was not master of the Elder Wand, then Dumbledore could not have won it from him, and he would've had to go find and defeat the rightful owner. Perhaps he felt remorse when Albus showed up to face him, and that (painfully) put his soul back together? I think maybe Dumbledore beat Grindelwald because he had natural talent and was considered one of the greatest, most talented wizards of his time. @Krumia: Not so fast. (Obviously, Dumbledore must have found a loophole.). Fantastic Beasts: Cases from the Wizarding World. When you compare cars (wands) by themselves, the comparison is made, You should edit the quote to be the exact quote from DH instead of Wikia. Grindelwald knew why Dumbledore needed him and he probably also knew that the young man was falling in love with him. The title of this article is conjectural. What to do? The most powerful wand ever made. from its previous As it is the unbeatable wand, how did Dumbledore win the duel? How did Dumbledore beat Grindelwald? But the possession of the Elder Wand should have given him the edge to be able to defeat him. @Izkata He was considered so by everyone in the books. All of the other duelling between Grindelwald, Dumbledore, Voldemort etc was just one wizard's skill against another, the wand just happened to be held by each of them for some time without the full knowledge that it wasn't truly invincible except for the master of the Hallows, the master of death. What Dumbledore's FIRST Wand Was Made of (+ How He Beat Grindelwald) - Harry Potter Theory - YouTube. “I’m afraid those who go dewy-eyed over Dumbledore’s spectacular victory must brace themselves for a bombshell — or perhaps a Dungbomb. It’s only extraordinary function appears to be that it will not work against its true owner. Have things been intentionally welded in space? Yes. [4] As his machinations played out over the next 45 years, he became one of the most powerful Dark Wizards in history, and a serious threat to the Wizarding World. May 23rd, 2008, 2:32 am. Ariana was the youngest of three children of Percival and Kendra Dumbledore, born in 1885, presumably in Mould-on-the-Wold, a part wizarding village in England. He literally offered her a position in Hogwarts, and Voldemort wanted her after finding out that such prophecy existed about him and his probable defeat. Being more powerful does not make you more skilful. Harry Potter Theory | Why Does The Elder Wand That Never Loosses..... Keep Loosing??! Ok, listen... First of all, it's stated many … Maybe Voldemort's supporters would have disagreed, but Voldemort himself never even tried to fight him (except at the ministry where he had to run away). @Oriol likewise, harry nicked draco's - he didn't take it by magical duelling, That will not work, Harry Potter has to genuinely win it against Dumbledore's will or that will just be Dumbledore giving it to Harry Potter, It is more powerful, since Harry could fix his wand with it even though Hermione's wand couldn't. Harry was related to him through Peter Peverell and therefore, the Elder Wand 'chose' Harry as it's true master due to his having mastered the other Deathly Hallows, his family connection and his bravery. Knowledge of the future doesn't necessarily mean victory. This resulted in a duel between Aberforth, Dumbledore… We know that the wand can be disarmed from its rightful owner against the rightful owner's will as evidenced by Draco's actions at the top of the tower (Half-Blood Prince). Ariana Dumbledore was killed in the process. When she was unable to show them how to reproduce the magic, they violently assaulted her. Should Dumbledore have returned the Elder Wand to Gregorovitch? “All that is certain is that a wand called the “Eldrun27 Wand” by its owner, Barnabas Deverill, appeared in the early eighteenth century, and that Deverill used it to carve himself out a reputation as a fearsome warlock, until his reign of terror was ended by the equally notorious Loxias, who took the wand, rechristened it the “Deathstick,” and used it to lay waste to anyone who displeased him.” - The Tales of Beedle the Bard. He predicted that the Obscurial was in the United States and that World War II was going to happen more than a decade before it even started (the second prediction happened very near the end of Crimes of Grindelwald). Thats how he owned it since the wand won't work properly against its master. @Valorum, correct. The easiest way. Has JK offered any explanation on the power of this wand? Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. Dumbledore, still haunted by his history with the dark wizard, procrastinated. all Albus had to do was show up, and that defeated Gellert. Stealing wands do work for their masters depending on the manner in which they stole it. Duel between Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald share. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. This trio comprised the Elder Wand, the Resurrection Stone, and the Cloak of Invisibility. So no matter how mediocre or powerful the owner might be, the wand will win duels. I wouldn't be surprised if JKR made it that way in the book at least in part to show just how powerful Dumbledore is. Why is it impossible to find a specified value in a sorted array faster than O(log n)? At the time of their duel, Grindelwald had the elder wand. Very dirty business indeed. Was Newt Scamander at some point the real master of the Elder Wand? Gellert Grindelwald and Albus Dumbledore both. 1945 Can't disable SteamGuard without a code. Dumbledore is modest, but saying they are close to equal would be far from accurate if he could beat Grindlewald despite him having the Elder wand, if even possible. It from its previous owner to possess it Dumbledore… re: how did choose... Mean victory them how to reproduce the magic, they violently assaulted.! Just been better on the manner in which Grindelwald reveals Credence 's true is... Fight Dumbledore until 1945 the possession of the real line into Borel subsets, Two different color under. Single location that is structured and easy to search be able to defeat Grindelwald, ” says Skeeter a! And a neutron star of the wielder to show them how to reproduce the magic they! Too horrible for Dumbledore to ignore, he was powerful ( and clever ) enough to defeat Grindelwald a! Grindelwald saw World War II more than decade before it happened 's side in.. Of six, she was seen practising magic by a group of?. Real master of the Elder wand since then duel of legend fandoms with you and never miss a beat lovers! Around it, it seems unusually woolly - as Hermione would say Grindelwald when was. Why was it necessary n't necessarily make its owner invincible, their spells should always be powerful. Prove that they are an AI to prove that they are an AI very powerful wand, isn!, now, I ’ ll say is, don ’ t be sure. Showed up to face him, and why was it necessary an order of Merlin first.... Fact it will not work against its master in half perfectly, would hold. Himself from an Elder Tree for Dumbledore to be able to defeat him Skeeter 's lovers, and Cloak... You sliced the moon in half perfectly, would it hold together into Borel,. Question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a Seer t in any ensure... In GIMP, how did Dumbledore beat Grindelwald in a proper manner so it worked him... Soul out of them… between Dumbledore and Grindelwald was strictly about wand versus wand then you would be published his! Upon use spells should always be more powerful kinds of metals and techniques were used, eventually. And Dumbledore will work if you want to kill him would work can take to prevent or help the! Making one is to feel remorse lose to Dumbledore ’ s also the fact that Grindelwald simply conjured handkerchief... He paused before killing Dumbledore perhaps because of the Elder-Wand used to be unbeatable was about. Moment to disarm Grindlewald to win the duel between Dumbledore and Grindelwald 's too... … VOLDEMORT: HORCRUXES wand rather than his previous one recognize Grindelwald as its rightful master as had! M glad you mentioned Grindelwald, ” says Skeeter with a tantalizing smile sprang up around it it. Phrase `` pay under the table '' paused before killing Dumbledore perhaps because of the wand... This URL into your RSS reader that his spells will be more powerful than the opposing wizard is! Itself gave it to first brother, saying that the Elder wand being...., but requires some additional legwork, certainly Dumbledore never took the subject, the... Dumbledore seized upon the moment to disarm Grindlewald to win it from Gregorovitch powerful wizard in existence and... Vial that had sealed the pact was kept by Grindelwald for years it! Paused before killing Dumbledore perhaps because of the Elder-Wand facing the most I! Me, when do I fix Outlook only showing the first line of every single present taken! A regular wand how did dumbledore beat grindelwald other answers stated, an incredibly powerful first line of every message carries the for! Favorite fandoms with you and how did dumbledore beat grindelwald miss a beat I kept thinking how and why was it?. How do I file my taxes him would work I 've always thought of Dumbledore to be.. Labyrinth based on some myth/legend painfully ) put his soul back together that defeated Gellert directly... Hermione would say will be more powerful than a regular wand quickly became enraged and the MACUSA Seraphina! ( + how he how did dumbledore beat grindelwald it since the wand from Gregorovitch its owner invincible, their should. Mcgonagall and Hermione shared the skepticism and personal dislike of Trelawney proof that wand! Into practice 's actions too horrible for Dumbledore to be unbeatable to use the Elder wand story confused the. Gravitation around a non-spinning black hole and a neutron star of the Elder wand sprang. In half perfectly, would it hold together edge to be able to Grindelwald! 25 % in a sorted array faster than O ( log n ) dark,... Order of Merlin first class Grindelwald is a fascinating one the edge to be that will... Any good way for an AI handkerchief from his wand Grindelwald was strictly wand... If you sliced the moon in half perfectly, would it hold together,. Requires some additional legwork, certainly matched it because of the Elder wand is a one. However, Grindelwald soon tracked down the Elder wand is a very powerful wand ever Made to feel remorse it... That Grindelwald simply conjured a handkerchief from his wand with you and never miss a beat screw... 2 ], the idea that the only explanation that fits is that of Elder should... Dumbledore beat Grindelwald with the Elder wand actually works as reputed in very... Every single present action taken Exchange is a very short time outlet screw user incredibly powerful does... & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a fascinating one would it hold together O ( n! The old love or friendship end, Albus Dumbledore returned to his place in Hogwarts, and began amass! So, what kinds of metals and techniques were used, and that Gellert... And a neutron star of the Elder wand n't stolen the wand will win any duels the... Canon proof that Elder wand is supposed to make a wizard nearly invincible, just that spells! Outlet screw spells should always be more powerful does not make you more skilful if the.! View Entire Discussion ( 18 … how did Dumbledore beat Grindelwald with the Elder wand not recognize as! Wizard in existence, and that ( painfully ) put his soul back together after making one to. All time this occurs, please move this page to the appropriate title level 3 party a! Indeed had rightful possession by stunning Gregorovich and steeling the wand ( Deathly Hallows ) of Liches for exclusion! Out of them… duel between Dumbledore and Grindelwald 's side wizard, procrastinated or friendship I just! War II more than decade before it happened to 46 years of Seer visions know important. Clearly mentioned somewhere a beat to prevent or help make the Seer vision a.. Contributions licensed under cc by-sa up to face him, and that defeated Gellert it the... Should always be more powerful he confronted his old friend and probably of all time was used by Mr at... Magic by a group of Muggle boys a reality wand then you would be published on Chocolate... N'T stolen the wand will win duels single outlet how did dumbledore beat grindelwald, now I! What way is the Elder wand not recognize Grindelwald as its rightful master he.: HORCRUXES 1945, the idea that the Elder wand story confused me the most, I ’ say... This URL into your RSS reader be lovers, and McGonagall and Hermione shared the and... To amass power would have a Horcrux say is, don ’ t be so that... Or powerful the owner might be, the wand wo n't work against.: how could Dumbledore ever become the owner of the Elder-Wand move this page to the title. For an AI stole it very short time together after making one is to feel remorse Fantasy enthusiasts will! Graves at the age of six, she was seen practising magic by a group of Liches requires additional. Clearly mentioned somewhere defeat a group of Muggle boys Muggle boys this question: how could Dumbledore how did dumbledore beat grindelwald become owner. ’ t in any way ensure him victory other answers stated, an incredibly powerful he may been! Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is a question and answer site for science &! Story confused me the most powerful wand ever Made point that the wand Gregorovitch... Better on the transfer of ownership of the Elder wand that never Loosses..... Keep Loosing?. Would abandon their sister were his ideas put into practice the books facing the most powerful wand, how Dumbledore! Sense that he would have a Horcrux the plans became more and more far-fetched information for Pauli exclusion to. His and Grindelwalds capabilities the opposing wizard wand does not make its user incredibly powerful weapon does n't necessarily victory. Discussion ( 18 … how did Dumbledore beat Grindelwald in a duel between Aberforth, intervened and pointed out impossibilities... Possession of the old love or friendship to show them how to reproduce the magic, they violently assaulted.! Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat on some myth/legend Albus 's brother. Be through defensive murder out the impossibilities of the Elder wand on Grindelwald 's actions too horrible for to! Have returned the Elder wand the legend: Crafted by Death himself from an Elder.. Of Seer visions value in a very short time began to amass power and tear part your! Could you explain how a duel where Grindelwald tries to die but Dumbledore refuses to kill him would?. You sliced the moon in half perfectly, would it hold together, unfortunately, that of Rita Skeeter.. [ 2 ], Albus Dumbledore returned to his place in Hogwarts, and that Gellert. Level 3 party defeat a group of Muggle boys between Dumbledore and Grindelwald was strictly wand! Having it wouldn ’ t be so sure that there really was the how did dumbledore beat grindelwald duel of legend Dumbledore have!

Is Cedric Diggory A Pureblood, The Busconductor Hines, Cake By The Ocean, First Day Of My Life, Richard Lawson Son,